God Bless Criticism

Last week, I did something I didn’t want to do…

I reached out and attempted to build a bridge, even though it required stepping out of my comfort zone.  I picked up the phone and made a call, with the goal of smoothing things with someone who was willing to share that he was upset with me–but refused to specify how/why.

As I dialed, I could hear my little brother’s voice in my head: “Social media is where fights happen! You have to connect with people on a genuine level. Sit down face-to-face, or at least reach out by phone, to build real relationships…”

So I gave it an honest effort.  Rather than hashing out the issue in comments on Facebook (even though that’s where the disagreement started), I asked the angry person whether he was open to a phone conversation instead.

11.3.17 God Told Him to Shut Up (and he didn't listen)

The blog post in question is this one: God Bless Divorce.

I asked whether it’s wise for a pastor to brag about how many people are attending his services–even under the guise of bragging about God?  It’s especially complicated when that pastor suggests his divorce has something to do with God’s favor, and that the full offering plates (somehow) make the Devil look foolish.

My question was–and still is–how can we be sure God is the one orchestrating the senior minister’s divorce into more baptisms?… How does that work, exactly?

For the record, I censored the name of the pastor and the name of the church in the first blog post. But I’m not doing that now.

Now that I’ve tried a handful of times to open the doors of communication with Ryan privately (and failed), my dad and I talked about the details on the podcast.

Click here to listen.

Summarizing points:




#1.   I always much prefer an honest, angry email or message rather than a passive-aggressive note that you’re “praying for me,” followed by sticking your fingers in your ears.

#2.   Anyone who knows me, or who gives me the chance to explain, knows I welcome criticism about anything I’ve written, even from people I’ve never met.   I don’t put random stipulations on people (like “you need to have been in my youth group more recently than ten years ago,” for example.)

#3.  I feel bad for any Christian who doesn’t allow him/herself to have the blessing of being judged.  Many pastors of large churches are surrounded by layers of staff to protect them from unwanted criticism.  But, the rest of the Body has learned to do the exact, same thing by selectively blocking certain people on social media.  You only want to watch cat videos and hear a happy chorus of “I’m praying for you!” whenever you have a problem?

Easy! Just block everyone who makes you think.

Honestly, I understand how hard it is to hear criticism, especially if you’re already in the middle of an emotional crisis. (Listen to the podcast! Think of my toilet-paper story! I’ve had fragile moments, so I get it!)  🙂

But, I harp on the importance of being open to criticism, because finding the courage to do that (even when it’s hard) ultimately changed my life.  I’ve discovered it’s empowering!  It leads to mental toughness and a certain maturity that cannot come from hiding, and plugging our ears.

I teach my children how to appreciate criticism, even when the critic is wrong, because I can’t think of a more powerful gift I could give another person.


In closing, Ryan was partially correct a few weeks ago when he said that making a statement (like the Nashville Statement) “hinders the possibility of relationship in many ways.”

But he and Perry Noble should stop blaming “the statement” and recognize which person is really at fault.  Blame the individuals who build walls to protect themselves from disagreement.

9.1.17 Unanswered Questions (#3)

Unfortunately–it’s not just the “unchurched” who build walls.  Christians do it with each other, too.

To me, it’s a red flag when Christians talk about inclusion and dialog and then turn around and block each other. 

Unfortunately, the only way we can discuss that is if we come out from behind the walls we’ve built and face the possibility of criticism with courage.

2 thoughts on “God Bless Criticism

  1. Jasmine Ruigrok

    I’m sorry that you had to be on the receiving end of this experience, but your thoughts here were a good challenge for me. There have been people I’ve reached out to make amends with and had turn out really well and seen great restoration. Other people I’ve reached out to and, whilst forgiveness was given, I still had to work on my attitude (still do for a couple of deeper hurts; not to sound like a snowflake). There are others I’ve buried the hatchet with and moved on for the sake of not opening old wounds of the people closest to me. There’s another instance where someone made a poor attempt to build a bridge with me whom I didn’t make a big effort to reciprocate after witnessing their history of blame shifting and lack of responsibility. Was I right, was I wrong in how I handled one or all of these? Probably wrong in a lot of cases. Whilst I don’t think it’s necessary to be besties with everyone that breathes, I know scripture says so far as it depends on you, be at peace with all men. Sometimes peace means a parting of ways, but that shouldn’t be for a lack of effort at restoration; something I am guilty of in certain cases.

    Having said that, criticism has never been part of why these circumstances occurred on my part. I agree with you in welcoming criticism and becoming a better, stronger, well-rounded person as a result of being open to other people’s opinions, good and bad. Not being able to bear up under someone’s honest judgement of something you believe, what you do, or how you live should NEVER be grounds for disassociation. If you can’t handle someone disagreeing with you, that’s on you. Not them for being disagreeable.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. mrsmcmommy Post author

      Relationships are hard precisely for this reason. It takes two, willing individuals with similar goals (and radical commitment to PERSONAL integrity) for it to work out… Where does my responsibility end and theirs begin? I’m never totally sure how to answer that question…

      But, I do believe (hope) that God is pleased by my seeking. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s